COVID-19 Update: How We Are Serving and Protecting Our Clients

Published on:

Does Florida Law Require Bicycle Helmets? Will it Hurt My Injury Case If I Wasn’t Wearing One?

As a general rule, bicycle helmets are a smart safety investment in safety all cyclists, regardless of age or skill – especially in Florida, which has the unfortunate, long-running reputation as the most dangerous in the U.S. for riding. The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety reported of the thousands treated in hospital emergency rooms nationally for bicycling injuries, traumatic brain injuries account for 60 percent of deaths, 67 percent of hospital admissions and 33 percent of injuries. Only 17 percent of all cyclists killed in crashes were wearing helmets.

If you weren’t wearing a helmet at the time of your bicycle accident, it’s important to understand how that will – and won’t – affect your claims and/ or litigation.

What is Florida’s Bicycle Helmet Law?

bicycle accidentLegally, there is no universal bike helmet law in Florida. If you’re 16 or older, you don’t have to wear one. However, if you’re younger than that, the law says you must wear one that meets federal safety standards, fastened to your head security with a strap.

However, a defendant in a Fort Myers bicycle accident cannot use your decision to wear a bike helmet – or to ensure your child is wearing one – as a means to gain the upper hand in the case. The defense strategy, existing in some states that don’t expressly forbid it, involves asserting that a cyclist’s decision to forego the known protection of a helmet, is an act of contributory negligence resulting in exacerbated trauma that otherwise would not have been sustained, and therefore, defendant shouldn’t be responsible for the full extent of your injuries.

Florida law expressly prohibits this defense tactic.

F.S. 316.2065, which details bicycling rights and responsibilities, specifically states,”The failure of a person to wear a bicycle helmet or the failure of a parent or guardian to prevent a child from riding a bicycle without a bicycle helmet may not be considered evidence of negligence or contributory negligence.”

Undercutting assertions of contributory negligence is important. While a partially liable cyclist can still pursue damages against others involved (unlike unfortunate plaintiffs in several other states), contributory negligence F.S. 768.81 will proportionately slash the amount of money you can receive. For instance, if your total losses are tallied at $250,000, but a jury apportions you 30 percent fault, you shave 30 percent (or $75,000) right off the top of damages to which you would have otherwise been entitled. The most you could receive at that point would be $175,000. Maybe that doesn’t sound too bad, but factor in medical bills, lost wages and a long, painful recovery, you’re going to need all you can get.

Plaintiffs in any personal injury case want to avoid a finding of contributory negligence, but bike crash victims especially need to tread carefully. Their injuries are likely to be much more serious, thanks to the sheer size disparity between vehicles and the cyclist’s lack of protection from direct bodily impact at high force and awkward angles.  You’re going to need the benefit of your entire damage award, so you need a bike crash lawyer prepared to fight for you on it.

Wait – Why Fault? Isn’t Florida a No-Fault State for Auto Insurance?

Florida is indeed a no-fault state for auto insurance. F.S. 627.736 requires all auto insurance policies issued in the state to include personal injury protection (PIP) benefits, up to a maximum of $10,000 in medical and disability benefits (with several stipulations) and $5,000 in death benefits.  Normally, everyone’s own PIP insurance pays for their own injuries, and then if damages exceed a certain threshold, you can pursue the bodily injury liability coverage of the other driver (presuming you can prove they were negligent).

Bicycle crashes are special cases because while bikes are considered “vehicles” with regard to their right to share the road, cyclists aren’t required to carry auto insurance to be street legal. So if you’re struck by a car, you can collect PIP from the driver’s insurance. (Same goes for pedestrians.) If you have your own PIP insurance to cover your vehicle (or if you’re covered under a resident relative’s policy), you might access that instead if the other driver lacks insurance. You can still then pursue bodily injury liability insurance from the other driver.

If the other motorist doesn’t have insurance or doesn’t have enough insurance for your injuries, we’ll look into whether you have an uninsured/ underinsured motorist (UM/UIM) policy that can kick in and pay or help pay the difference.

Why is Cycling in Florida So Dangerous?

Florida has long held the undesirable rank of the worst state for cycling safety in America. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) reports in a single recent year, there were:

  • 818 bicyclist deaths in the U.S., accounting for 2.3 percent of all traffic deaths (a 12.2 percent year-over-year decrease).
  • 45,000 bicycle accident injuries, accounting for 1.8 percent of the total number of injured crash victims. (This figure likely understates the problem because not all injuries are officially recorded.)
  • 70 percent of fatal bicycle crashes occurred in urban areas (where riders are more likely to encounter the deadly combination of heavy traffic, limited road space and frequent intersections.)
  • 150 bicyclists were killed just in Florida that year, accounting for 5.1 percent of all motor vehicle deaths.
  • Factoring in population, Florida’s bicycle crash fatality rate was 7.4. Louisiana came in second at 7.3, but tallied far fewer actual deaths – 34. Third was Vermont, with a rate of 6.4 and a total of 4 deaths. California, which has double Florida’s population, was fourth in terms of raw numbers, with a total of 129 bike crash deaths and a rate of 3.3 per million.

If you’ve been in a crash, F.S. 95.11 allows a statute of limitations of up to four years to take action in a personal injury tort, but it’s best not to wait. Not only is it more expedient to begin investigation and case building immediately, the facts of your case (for example, a crash with an on-the-job city employee) may have tighter deadlines for certain paperwork. Partnering early with a South Florida bicycle accident attorney who knows Florida bike law and has extensive experience with insurer settlement negotiations and trial can be invaluable.

If you are injured in a Fort Myers bicycle accident, contact Fort Myers injury attorneys at The Garvin Firm at 239-277-0005 for a free initial consultation.

Additional Resources:

Pedestrians and bicyclists, 2016, Insurance Institute for Highway Safety

More Blog Entries:

Will the Florida Legislature finally protect Florida Drivers and their Wallet?, Nov. 14, 2017, Fort Myers Bicycle Accident Attorney Blog

Justia Lawyer Rating for Jeffrey R. Garvin
Florida Legal Elite 2016
Super Lawyers
Million Dollar Advocates Forum
The Best Lawyers in America
American Association for Justice
Florida Justice Association
Contact Information