COVID-19 Update: How We Are Serving and Protecting Our Clients

Published on:


Remove shackles unless offenders pose a clear threat

As they consider ways to make juvenile offenders safer in state custody, lawmakers should seize the opportunity to clarify state policy on one controversial practice — slapping leg irons and belly chains on youthful offenders, regardless of their age, physical strength or offense.

Lawmakers never officially approved the practice of shackling juveniles travelling to and from court. Yet it’s common procedure in courthouses across the state — even in circuits where adults accused of violent offenses are transported without the chains. Experts in juvenile justice lament the message the heavy shackles send to young offenders, many of whom are already terrified.

In September, the Florida Bar’s Committee on the Legal Status of Children recommended that lawmakers make it clear that shackles are only to be used when a juvenile represents a clear physical threat, either to himself, guards or fellow offenders. A commission appointed by Gov. Charlie Crist reached the same conclusion last month, after hearing from psychologists who said the shackles serve to disorient and traumatize youth, making them distrustful and sending the message that they are little more than animals. Several circuits, including Miami-Dade, have dropped the practice; Public Defender Jim Purdy, whose circuit includes Volusia and Flagler, has asked local judges to make the same call.

The extensive testimony makes it clear: A one-size-fits-all policy on chaining children is unnecessarily cruel and could be counter-productive. The Legislature should put a stop to it.

Posted in:
Published on:

One response to “CHILDREN IN CHAINS”

  1. Coach says:

    Police will do what is necessary to (1) Protect others (2) Protect the instigator (3) Protect them selves (4) Protect Property and do it pretty much in that order.

    Then they have transportation Issues to deal with. They did nothing to complain about and may have saved the child from serious injury.

    When I was a child a classmate went berserk and was handcuffed and beat his head on the inside of the police car. One of the officer sat in the back and held him while the other drove. They probably saved his life twice.

    Children must be restrained while transporting. MUST. They are too much of a danger to themselves. They do not recognize danger because they are children. They are in trouble – There primary instinct is to Flee – Flee anyway they can. If they were rational they would not be in this situation to start with.

    It is not cruel. It is absolutely necessary. A child bolts and runs in front of a car or jumps out a court house window and then the same very stupid bleeding heart liberal will be blaming someone else again – but not themselves.

    For the love of democracy – THINKS THINGS THROUGH.

Justia Lawyer Rating for Jeffrey R. Garvin
Florida Legal Elite 2016
Super Lawyers
Million Dollar Advocates Forum
The Best Lawyers in America
American Association for Justice
Florida Justice Association
Contact Information